Skip to content
DaveKibby

The conversation you keep not having

Most leaders have one. It gets rehearsed in the car, softened in the shower and postponed every Monday. What it costs is rarely what we think.

By Dave KibbyPublished 7 min read

Almost every leader is carrying one. A conversation that needs to happen and hasn't. It might be with a co-founder whose contribution has quietly fallen away. A senior colleague everyone tiptoes around. A board member, a partner at home, a long-standing friend in the business. You know the opening line. You have probably said it out loud to yourself more times than you would admit.

And still, the week fills up. There is a launch, a quarter end, a recruitment drive. The moment never seems quite right. So the conversation waits, and waiting begins to feel like a decision you haven't made.

Rehearsal is not preparation

Rehearsing a conversation feels productive. We refine the wording, anticipate objections, imagine the other person's face. But notice what usually happens in the rehearsal. It is rarely a conversation. It is a speech, followed by a reaction we are bracing for. We rehearse to protect ourselves from an outcome, not to discover anything.

That tells you something useful. If the rehearsal is mostly about managing how the other person will respond, then the conversation has become about something other than its subject. It has become about what it might say about you — that you are unkind, unfair, ungrateful, out of your depth, or simply the person who disturbed a fragile peace.

The delay is rarely about timing. It is usually about what the conversation might mean.

What waiting quietly costs

The obvious cost is the problem itself, left to grow. The less obvious cost is everything that bends around it. Meetings are designed to avoid the subject. Work is routed around the person. Other people notice, draw their own conclusions and adjust. A team learns, without anyone saying so, which topics are not discussed here.

There is a personal cost too. An unhad conversation takes up room. It sits in the background of other decisions, a small weight that makes everything slightly heavier. Leaders often describe a strange relief when it finally happens, out of all proportion to the content. That relief is a measure of how much energy the avoidance was using.

Look at the story, not the script

Instead of working on the words, it can help to look at the story you are telling yourself about the conversation. What do you assume will happen? What do you assume about the other person — that they will be hurt, angry, defensive, devastated? And what do you assume about yourself — that you won't handle it, that you'll be disliked, that you'll lose something you need?

Those assumptions are often older than the situation. Someone who learnt early that keeping the peace kept them safe will feel the pull to postpone with remarkable force, however senior they have become. Someone who learnt that being liked mattered more than being clear will find a hundred reasonable reasons to wait. None of this is a flaw. It is simply a way of seeing that once made sense and is now running the agenda.

When the assumption is seen for what it is, the conversation usually looks different. Smaller, sometimes. More human. Less like a confrontation and more like a long-overdue piece of honesty that both people may have been waiting for.

Start with what is true for you

Practical shifts help. Open with what you have noticed rather than a verdict. Say that you have been putting it off, and why. Ask a real question and be prepared to hear an answer you hadn't planned for. Treat the first conversation as the beginning of a conversation, not the delivery of a conclusion.

But the bigger shift is internal. The conversation becomes possible when it stops being a test of who you are. Then it is just a conversation — sometimes uncomfortable, often clarifying, and almost always less costly than the silence that came before it.

Related reading

Pressure and responsibility

When being the capable one becomes a constraint

Being the person who can always handle it is a genuine strength. At a certain point, it also becomes the ceiling — for you and for everyone around you.

7 min read